Unlock the Editor’s Digest totally free
Roula Khalaf, Editor of the FT, selects her favorite tales on this weekly e-newsletter.
Brian Niccol took cost of Chipotle Mexican Grill in 2018 because the burrito chain was struggling. A collection of meals security breaches had pushed away prospects, and traders have been deserting the shares of an organization nonetheless led by its founder.
After overseeing a turnaround that despatched Chipotle’s inventory value nearly 800 per cent greater, the 50-year-old was tapped on Tuesday to steer Starbucks, one other enterprise in want of revival with a self-described founder who casts an extended shadow over the enterprise. Buyers, looking forward to a repeat efficiency, drove the espresso chain’s shares up nearly 25 per cent.
“He’s a man who likes to make things better and remedy issues,” mentioned Craig Cappozzo, a pal and former colleague of Niccol. “He’s form of strolling into the identical state of affairs at Starbucks.”
Chipotle has stood out for its resilience this 12 months. Comparable gross sales for the Newport Seaside, California-based firm elevated 11 per cent in its newest quarter, in contrast with declines at fast-food opponents reminiscent of McDonald’s and KFC as diners eat extra meals at residence to offset surging restaurant inflation.
It’s a stark distinction with the disaster Niccol inherited on the fast-casual chain, the place a whole bunch of consumers had turn out to be unwell after consuming its meals, some with norovirus, in a public relations catastrophe that led to a $25mn nice from federal prosecutors.
Niccol arrived on the burrito chain with a popularity for understanding digital applied sciences, restaurant operations and branding, having served as chief govt of Yum Manufacturers’ Taco Bell chain and begun his profession at client merchandise group Procter & Gamble.
Analysts reminiscent of Bernstein’s Danilo Gargiulo credit score Niccol with having made Chipotle related once more, launching advertising and marketing that highlighted the standard and freshness of its components and upgrading its social media technique. As inflation raged on most eating places’ menu boards, Chipotle was much less aggressive with its value rises, Gargiulo added.
Cappozzo, who was Niccol’s supervisor when Niccol was a younger intern at P&G, mentioned his pal typically ordered three or 4 objects after they ate out collectively at Chipotle so he might examine the way it was served. When Cappozzo as soon as texted him a couple of 15 minute-long queue at his native department, Niccol texted again 10 minutes later to say he had talked to employees and brought care of the issue.
“He’s clearly a fantastic operator. He is aware of the main points of the enterprise are essential,” Cappozzo mentioned. When Walmart nominated Niccol to its board this 12 months, it hailed him as “a dynamic chief with a ardour for excellence”.
There are similarities between Chipotle in 2018 and Starbucks in 2024. Niccol took over the CEO function at Chipotle from its founder Steve Ells, however Ells stayed on as govt chair. At Starbucks he’s changing Laxman Narasimhan, who since beginning the job early final 12 months has not escaped public critiques from his predecessor Howard Schultz, the pioneer who constructed Starbucks into the world’s largest espresso chain.
By 2018, Chipotle had attracted the eye of an activist investor within the form of Invoice Ackman’s Pershing Sq.. This 12 months, activist Elliott Funding Administration has taken a stake in Starbucks and made the same push for modifications.
However there are additionally important variations between the 2 corporations. Chipotle owns greater than 3,500 eating places and has about 116,000 staff, nearly all within the US. Starbucks has practically 40,000 cafés, employs near 400,000 individuals and operates in dozens of nations, together with China.
Within the US, greater than 470 Starbucks places at the moment are represented by a labour union. Chipotle has one unionised department.
Chipotle’s menu is comparatively easy and secure, providing patrons a cafeteria-style choice. Niccol’s mainstay meal is a burrito with white rice, hen, gentle salsa, corn salsa, fajita veggies and cheese with a facet of guacamole and chips, in keeping with an organization proxy assertion. That very same submitting disclosed that Niccol’s complete pay hit $22.5mn final 12 months — 1,354 instances the median worker’s pay — and valued his unrealised features from previous fairness incentive grants at greater than $82mn.
Starbucks specialises in drinks, not meals, however they’re recognized for his or her fiendish complexity. The rising reputation of takeout and app orders has sophisticated the job of baristas, resulting in longer wait instances and frustrations on both facet of the counter.
The duty of simplifying operations has been one in every of many challenges uppermost in Starbucks traders’ minds. They’ve but to listen to Niccol’s plans for tackling inflation-wearied US customers, more durable competitors in China, boycotts of western manufacturers over Israel’s conflict in Gaza, negotiations with unionised baristas or Schultz’s critiques.
For now, nonetheless, they’re betting that he can repeat at the least a few of the success he loved at Chipotle.
The announcement of Niccol’s arrival added $21bn to Starbucks’ market capitalisation on Tuesday, bringing it to $108.7bn. Chipotle misplaced nearly $6bn in worth to shut with a market cap of $71bn.
“Proper now he’s thought-about to be nearly the LeBron James or the Tom Brady or the Messi of the restaurant business,” Gargiulo mentioned.
